diff --git a/ext/bg/js/settings/clipboard-popups-controller.js b/ext/bg/js/settings/clipboard-popups-controller.js
index 4737b0b7..cd1c2057 100644
--- a/ext/bg/js/settings/clipboard-popups-controller.js
+++ b/ext/bg/js/settings/clipboard-popups-controller.js
@@ -67,7 +67,7 @@ class ClipboardPopupsController {
 
         this._setToggleValid(toggle, true);
 
-        await this._settingsController.setProfileSetting('clipboard.enableBackgroundMonitor', value);
+        await this._settingsController.setProfileSetting(toggle.dataset.clipboardSetting, value);
     }
 
     _onPermissionsChanged({permissions: {permissions}}) {